Search toggle
Say hello.
Focus Str. 5th Ave, 98/2 34746 Manhattan, New York
+1 222 44 55
Real Briefings

Design Review Board

BEL-DRB-2025-06-17 June 17, 2025 Design Review Committee City of Bellingham 90 min
← Back to All Briefings
Jun
Month
17
Day
90
Min
Published
Status

The Design Review Board conducted an early design guidance session for a proposed 36-unit, four-story multifamily residential building at the corner of Forest Street and Maple Street in downtown Bellingham. The project, presented by development team Ali Taysi, property owner Brett Bennett, and architect Sergio Ruiz, proposes to demolish an existing two-story office building while preserving its foundation to support the new construction. The board's discussion centered heavily on the proposed common usable space located within the parking lot area, with members expressing concerns about its functionality and visual appeal from the street. Board members Robert Wright and Ryan Van Straten advocated for raising the common space to basement level to create better separation from parking areas and improve the pedestrian experience along Maple Street. The architectural approach deliberately avoids mimicking nearby historic structures like the YWCA and Majestic buildings, instead pursuing a contemporary design consistent with other recent residential developments in the area. The board provided constructive feedback on building massing, material choices, and the importance of extending architectural elements to all visible facades. No formal departures from design standards were requested at this early stage, and the applicant expressed appreciation for the board's guidance on the challenging usable space requirements.

**Early Design Guidance Provided:** - Motion to recommend raising common usable space to basement level for better functionality and street presence - Guidance to extend building massing projections to the north (alley-side) facade for architectural consistency - Recommendation to add pedestrian gates on both ends of the common space for improved connectivity - Direction to prioritize visual…

About 50% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
**Common Usable Space Design Standards:** The most substantial discussion focused on meeting multifamily design standards for common usable space. The 3,560 square feet proposed in the parking area must meet prescriptive dimensional requirements while providing meaningful recreational value for residents. Board members expressed concern that the space, surrounded by nose-in parking on multiple sides, would feel "trapped" and less usable. Lindsay Kirshner explained that the code allows for double-counting space (1,780 square feet counting as 3,560) when enhanced amenities are provided above minimum requirements. This creates flexibility for including basketball courts, pickleball, or other active recreation within the fenced area. **…
About 50% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
**Development Team (Ali Taysi, Brett Bennett, Sergio Ruiz):** Advocated for preserving the existing foundation to reduce shoring costs and construction complexity on the sloping site. Emphasized that the building location and massing were driven by foundation reuse, site topography, and alley access requirements. Proposed contemporary materials (brick veneer, fiber cement panels) to differentiate from historic neighbors. **Design Review Board Members:** - Robert Wright: Strongly advocated for raising the common space above alley level and extending architectural massing to the north faca…
About 49% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
**Ali Taysi, on historic context:** "We feel like you'd be better off doing something that's entirely different from those, so that they maintain their like uniqueness within the district, versus trying to draw like one or two elements from them to create like a caricature, so to speak, of those." **Robert Wright, on the common space:** "I'd have a hard time envisioning it truly being an interactive and fully usable space with both of the rows of parking kind of facing it." **Ryan Van Strate…
About 50% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →

**Subsequent Design Development:** The applicant will return with revised plans incorporating board guidance on common space elevation, pedestrian circulation, and massing consistency. Detailed material specifications, window patterns, and parapet treatments will be refined based on feedback. **Permit Review Process:** Following design review approval, the project will proceed through standard permitting processes including civil engineering review for site …

About 49% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
**Design Direction Established:** The common usable space concept shifted from a street-level parking lot amenity to an elevated platform providing better visual presence and user experience. This represents a significant change in site design approach. **Architectural Language Clarified:** The contemporary design approach was validated by the board, establishing clear direction away from historic mimicry toward consistency with recent neighborhood development. **Massing Strategy Refined:** The recommendation to extend projecting ele…
About 49% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
## Meeting Overview On the afternoon of June 17, 2025, the Bellingham Design Review Board convened for a routine meeting focused on a single but substantial agenda item: early design guidance for a proposed 36-unit multifamily residential building at 1101 North Forest Street. The meeting, held in City Council chambers with both in-person and virtual participation options, brought together board members Maggie Bates, Robert Wright, Coby Jones, and chair Ryan Van Straten, along with city staff Lindsay Kirshner and Fiona Starr. The session centered on a development proposal from Ali Taysi's team, including property owner Brett Bennett (who will also serve as general contractor) and project architect Sergio Ruiz. Their project represents the kind of urban infill development increasingly common in Bellingham's downtown core—demolishing an existing two-story office building while preserving its foundation to support a new four-story residential structure with 29 parking spaces and common amenities. What made this meeting particularly engaging was the substantive discussion around the practicalities of urban design: how to create usable open space in a constrained site, how to respect historic context without resorting to architectural mimicry, and how to balance resident privacy with streetscape activation. The board's questions probed beyond surface-level aesthetics to examine the lived experience of future residents and pedestrians. ## The Foundation-First Design Approach The project team's decision to preserve and reuse the existing building's foundation shaped every aspect of their design proposal. As Ali Taysi explained during his presentation, "that sloping site, combined with the existing building foundation attempting to retain that, and then taking access for any parking off of the alley kind of drove like the 10,000-foot level site design." This pragmatic approach emerged from hard-won experience. Project architect Sergio Ruiz noted that property owner Brett Benn…
About 15% shown — sign up free to read the rest Sign up free →
### Meeting Overview The City of Bellingham Design Review Board met on June 17, 2025, to provide early design guidance for a proposed 36-unit, four-story multifamily residential building at 1101 N Forest Street. The main focus was reviewing the proposed design's consistency with urban village design standards and providing guidance on challenging site constraints, particularly regarding the common usable open space placement within the parking lot area. ### Key Terms and Concepts **Design Review Board (DRB):** City board that reviews new building designs in designated districts to ensure consistency with design standards and community character. **Early Design Guidance:** First formal design review meeting where applicants present conceptual plans and receive feedback before finalizing detailed designs. **Urban Village Design Standards:** City regulations that guide building design, massing, materials, and site planning in designated urban village areas. **Common Usable Space:** Required outdoor amenity area for multifamily developments, minimum 100 square feet per unit, that must meet specific size and programming requirements. **Design Intent Statements:** Specific goals within design standards that projects must meet, focusing on building character, public realm interface, and neighborhood compatibility. **Setback:** Distance a building must be positioned back from the property line, often used for landscaping buffers or privacy. **Massing:** Three-dimensional composition of a building's overall form, including projections, recesses, and height variations. **SEPTED:** Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design principles that promote safety through visibility and natural surveillance. ### Key People at This Meeting | Name | Role / Affiliation | |---|---| | Ryan Van Straten | Design Review Board Chair | | Maggie Bates | Design Review Board Member | | Robert Wright | Design Review Board Member | | Coby Jones | Design Review Board Member | | Lindsay Kirshner | City Planning Staff, Project Planner | | Fiona Starr | City Administrative Staff | | Ali Taysi | Development Team Member | | Brett Bennett | Property Owner and General Contractor | | Sergio Ruiz | Project Architect | ### Background Context The proposed development sits on a corner parcel at Fo…
About 49% shown — premium members only Upgrade to premium →

Share This Briefing